By Joshua Kucerajan
On Dec. 26, authorities in Azerbaijan raided the local
bureau of Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty, a U.S. government-funded service,
seizing computers and ordering the office shut down. Earlier that month, police
had arrested Khadija Ismayilova, a RFE/RL reporter and the country’s most
prominent investigative journalist, on dubious charges of inciting someone to
commit suicide. (The alleged victim has since recanted the accusation, but Ms.
Ismayilova remains in jail.)
These events have been reported abroad largely as marking
a further constriction in Azerbaijan’s already tiny space for alternative
points of view. And they are that. But they also suggest a dramatic change in
the geopolitics of the volatile Caspian Sea region: the Azerbaijani
government’s growing hostility toward Washington.
Azerbaijan is in a prime location, wedged between Russia
and Iran on the oil- and gas-rich Caspian Sea. Since gaining independence from
the Soviet Union in 1991, it has been a strong partner of the United States. It
has worked with Washington to break Russia’s energy monopoly in the region by
supporting the construction of oil and gas pipelines to Turkey. It is a key
transit point for military cargo to and from Afghanistan. And the government in
Baku has forged close ties with Israel, based primarily on the trade of
weaponry and oil.
A 2009 U.S. diplomatic cable described Azerbaijan’s
foreign policy as characterized by “pragmatism, restraint and a helpful bias
toward integration with the West.” Baku’s orientation toward the West was
always in service of two priorities: maintaining its grip on power and taking
back the territory of Nagorno-Karabakh, which Azerbaijan lost to ethnic
Armenian separatists in the early 1990s. But as Russia’s dramatic new foreign
policy changes the strategic landscape across Eurasia, Baku appears to be recalculating
whether its ties to the West really are advancing its own goals.
The attack on RFE/RL followed months of extreme
anti-Western rhetoric. Top Azerbaijani government officials have accused the
United States ambassador to Baku of “gross interference” and former Foreign
Minister Carl Bildt of Sweden of being an American spy. In early December, the
president's chief of staff, Ramiz Mehdiyev, published a 13,000-word article
claiming that the C.I.A. was contriving regime changes in the post-Soviet space
(the so-called color revolutions). It also called Azerbaijan’s human rights
activists a “fifth column” of the United States.
The dominant criticism is that Washington, acting through
NGOs and human rights groups, is trying to destabilize the Azerbaijani government.
In fact, human rights activists have criticized American and European
governments for being too soft on Baku. Washington has called the raid on
RFE/RL merely “cause for concern.” In spite of Azerbaijan’s dismal human rights
record, it has been awarded prestige projects like the chairmanship of the
Council of Europe’s Committee of Ministers in 2014, and it will be hosting the
European Games this summer.
Continue reading the main storyContinue reading the main
storyContinue reading the main story
Anti-American rhetoric from Baku is not unheard of, but
its recent intensity, seemingly unprompted, and its reliance on Kremlin talking
points suggest a shift toward Moscow.
Russia has a collective security agreement with Armenia,
maintains a large military base there and provides the country with discounted
weaponry. It’s never been clear how Russia might intervene in a war between
Armenia and Azerbaijan over Nagorno-Karabakh, but Baku’s repudiation of America
makes Russia less inclined to get involved in a fight against Azerbaijan.
The United States, for its part, will never intervene
militarily on Azerbaijan’s side. And the payoff for Baku of putting up with
Washington’s hectoring on democracy and human rights shrinks as the West loses
influence worldwide. It’s a measure of the Azerbaijani government’s disdain of
Washington that the raid on RFE/RL was conducted just days after Secretary of
State John Kerry spoke with President Ilham Aliyev on the phone.
In an interview in December, Ali Hasanov, a top presidential
adviser, was asked why the government began to so sharply criticize the United
States but not Iran or Russia. “Because they don’t criticize us, that’s why,”
he said. “Russia, Iran, and China, too, deal with us on the basis of
noninterference in our internal affairs.”
Washington, meanwhile, increasingly judges partner
nations according to their opposition to Russia. At her confirmation hearing in
September, the new United States ambassador to Uzbekistan — one of the most
repressive governments on the planet — praised the country as “an increasingly
important partner,” thanks to “its deliberate, reliable resistance to Russian
pressure.” Azerbaijan’s mimicry of Russian rhetoric and rapprochement with
Moscow is an implicit threat to Washington: Give us what we want, or we’ll go
over to Russia.
The United States doesn’t need to give in to this
blackmail. Yes, the stakes are high: As Washington works to isolate Russia
economically, Azerbaijani natural gas has become an even more important
alternative to Russian gas for European customers. And Baku’s geopolitical
shift could upset the fragile balance that has kept tensions over
Nagorno-Karabakh from turning into a full-scale war.
But it would be short-sighted for Washington to sacrifice
its principles just to shore up support against Russia. Moscow’s current
geopolitical moment is only temporary. While the pro-Russia forces in Baku
appear to be ascendant for the time being, other powerful blocs favor closer
ties to the West.
Failing to stand up for human rights and democracy,
including the rights of its own RFE/RL, would make the United States look weak
and sap its supporters. Expecting to be arrested, Ms. Ismayilova herself asked
foreign governments to speak loudly in defense of the dozens of political prisoners
in Azerbaijan. “I don’t believe in human rights advocacy behind closed doors,”
she wrote. “People of my country need to know that human rights are supported.”
Joshua Kucera is a journalist and author of The Bug Pit,
a blog on military and security issues in Eurasia.
Hiç yorum yok:
Yorum Gönder
Not: Yalnızca bu blogun üyesi yorum gönderebilir.